GIACOMO PUCCINI IS ETERNAL, MADAMA BUTTERFLY A PUCCINIAN GEM AND A 2004 MET PERFORMANCE FASCINATING TO LISTEN!

In the book “Giacomo Puccini”, author Conrad Wilson's first line of the preface is: “Puccini, even if we refuse to admit it, is the composer through whom we learn to love opera.” How right Wilson is.

Puccini was handsome, elegant and a celebrity acclaimed by the whole world. He had an ardent entente with the opposite sex. In a remarkable list of mistresses, his predilection for sopranos is evident. In 1904, he had a brief love affair in London with the cultured and beautiful Sybil Seligman, married to a banker, then kept a lifelong friendship and letter correspondence with her. In 1911, he met the German baroness Josephine von Stangel at Viareggio and started a passionate liaison with her, lasting six years. He enjoyed life, pursued motoring and hunting. He admired Wagner's Parsifal and Verdi's Aida. Of all his contemporaries, he showed affinity for Mahler, Lehár and felt that Richard Strauss was his most serious competitor. Of sopranos, he was impressed by  Jeritza and Darclee, of tenors by Caruso, Gigli and Lauri-Volpi.

He could have been one of the greatest operatic composers in the world. He had an unmatched talent for melody, great knack for drama and ability to orchestrate as well as Wagner or Verdi, from modernistic and stylistic viewpoints. It is an awful pity that innate melancholia, pessimism and an insecure marriage to Elvira afflicted him.

He spent considerable time revising his own scores and wasted precious time searching for and rejecting tens of subjects for opera. The end-result was an ephemeral sequence of only 12 operas in 40 years,

However, half of the operas he wrote are true, precious gems and in popular eternal demand. Madama Butterfly, one of the greatest lyrical-tragic operas of all times and in the composer's own words: The most felt and suggestive opera I have ever conceived , marks a return to psychological drama, intimacy, attentive description of feelings and le piccole cose . Belasco's play and its exquisite Japanese hero bowled Puccini over.

He did considerable research to ensure that the opera's musical idiom was authentic, studying even the score of The Mikado. In a unique lyrical style, Puccini perfectly assimilated authentic Japanese melodies, used the pentatonic scale and various exotic instruments admirably. The technical level of the opera is very high due to melodic plasticity, harmony, orchestral colour and measured use of Leitmotiv as a function of expressive requirements.

The opera premiere was a colossal fiasco mainly due to a hostile audience. Puccini revised the opera by cutting the long second act into two and making other changes. When presented at the Teatro Grande di Brescia three months later, in May 1904, the revised opera scored a triumphant success, which launched it to a rapid conquest of the world major opera theatres.

In the opera, Pinkerton, the handsome philandering American navy officer, is to be damned on moral principles but is very original in terms of role characterisation. He drinks whisky and toasts with Sharpless, the American consul, to the forthcoming nuovissimi legami . He plays up with Cio-Cio-San known as Butterfly, a vulnerable hero, insensibly. Pinkerton means no good, vehemently and irresponsibly in pursuit of a futile marriage to satisfy his erotic impulses in contrast with Cio-Cio-San's wishful sentiments and frailty of a geisha in love.

In the love scene of act I, the spouses express contrasting feelings but seal them with a long kiss under a starry sky of a night serena, dove dorme ogni cosa. The love scene has an ebb and flow of ardour and sentiment, is the most perfectly structured, atmospheric, melodious and longest of all Puccini's love scenes. In the second act, Pinkerton's conspicuous absence throws Butterfly down an empty spiral of pain and despair. In the arioso "Addio fiorito asil" of the third act, Pinkerton is late and excruciatingly remorseful for having negated Butterfly's faithfulness and love. They stand for a Puccini's artistic invention without precedent.

 

 

 

Madama Butterfly act I – The bridal party encounter with Pinkerton and Sharpless

 

The admirable soprano lirico-drammatico Veronica Villarroel sings Cio-Cio-San

 

Audio Files

The love scene duet part 1 sung by Cio-Cio-San (soprano Veronica Villarroel) and Pinkerton (tenor Marco Berti) – Madama Butterfly act I

The love scene duet part 2 sung by Cio-Cio-San (soprano Veronica Villarroel) and Pinkerton (tenor Marco Berti) – Madama Butterfly act I

Both files were extracted from a January 2004 performance of Madama Butterfly at the Met, radio broadcast under the auspices of The Chevron Texaco and Metropolitan Opera. The Companies present an opera performance on the air each Saturday, from December to April, to millions of people around the globe.

 

Legal Disclaimer

 

(j.f.)

<< back to archive

 



Opera is a spectacular art form combining music, action and words, where the drama or comedy is enhanced by the words, sung in the original or other language. Instrumental works draw great attention and delight from the sound of the music alone but opera has a triple edge advantage: Music, action and words sung by the human voice, the supreme instrument.

Register now to see all site contents and keep updated on the latest features!

The site's favourite quote

General George Armstrong Custer on the eve of the battle at the Little Bighorn River in Montana (June 1876) cited:

There is one thing to be said for glory - you can take glory with you, when it is your time to go


The Panel
s.f. Salvatore Fisichella
j.f. Joseph Fragala
g.m. Geoff Mallinson
a.t. Andrei Turcu
k.s. Keith Shilcock
d.t. Dragos Tomescu             m.m. Michèle Muller